What Should You Check Before Ordering Proxy Cards for a New Deck?

Ordering proxies is much easier when the decklist and print files are checked before checkout. Most disappointing results come from small issues that were already present in the source files or order setup: blurry images, duplicate cards, wrong dimensions, unreadable custom text, or a quantity that does not match the final list.

A quick pre order check can prevent an entire batch from needing correction.

Confirm the Decklist First

Make sure the list you are ordering is the list you actually want to test. It sounds obvious, but decks change quickly during brewing. Compare the order against your latest deck builder version and check quantities, basic lands, tokens, sideboard cards, and Commander options.

If you are still making major swaps every day, it may be worth testing another round before placing a larger order.

Inspect Every Card Image

Open questionable images at full size. Look closely at card names, mana symbols, rules text, collector information, and artwork edges. Low resolution files can produce fuzzy text even if the preview thumbnail looks fine.

Custom artwork deserves extra attention. Check the crop and make sure important parts of the image are not sitting too close to trim areas.

Readability matters more than novelty. A card that looks striking but takes extra time to identify can become annoying during repeated games.

Check Size, Backs, and Print Setup

Confirm the card dimensions expected by the printer. Small sizing errors become noticeable once proxies are mixed with standard cards in sleeves.

Decide what you need on the back. If the cards will always be played in opaque sleeves, the back may matter less, but you should still understand what will be printed.

Before deciding Where to buy MTG proxies for playtesting, compare practical order details such as minimum quantities, accepted file formats, cardstock information, finish options, cutting standards, and how previews are handled.

Think About How You’ll Use Them

A testing deck has different needs from a custom Cube or a display focused project. For frequent shuffling, consistent size and cardstock matter a lot. For custom designs, color accuracy and artwork reproduction may deserve more attention.

Consider sleeves before ordering too. If your proxies are slightly different in finish or appearance from real cards, opaque sleeves help keep the deck consistent during play.

Review the Order One Last Time

Check total card count against the decklist. Look for duplicates caused by uploading a file twice. Verify front and back assignments if the ordering system supports custom backs. Finally, inspect any generated preview rather than assuming the uploaded file will be automatically corrected.

Conclusion

A good proxy order starts before anything is printed. Confirm the decklist, inspect image quality, verify dimensions, understand the cardstock and finish, and make sure the order matches how you plan to use the cards. Spending a few extra minutes on those checks is much easier than finding a preventable mistake after the deck arrives.